The Porsche 718, whether the Cayman or Boxster model, is a fantastic sports car known for its precision handling, balanced mid-engine layout, and pure driving pleasure. But how does it stack up against its rivals in the high-performance sports car segment? Let’s take a closer look at how the 718 compares to some of its top competitors, and why it remains the enthusiasts choice.
Porsche 718 vs BMW M2
The BMW M2 is a pocket rocket, offering a rear-wheel-drive platform, aggressive styling, and a powerful straight-six engine. It’s a thrilling car, with plenty of grunt and serious fun to drive. However, the M2’s front-engine layout and slightly heavier feel can’t quite match the mid-engine balance and precision of the Porsche 718. The 718 is more poised in corners, with handling that the M2 (in our opinion) can’t quite match.
For a deeper dive into the Porsche 718 vs. BMW M2 comparison, you can read our full article here
Porsche 718 vs Alpine A110
The Alpine A110 is a lightweight contender, celebrated for its agility and driving purity. With a mid-engine layout similar to the 718, it offers a raw and engaging experience that’s hard to beat. However, while the A110’s lightweight construction makes it nimble, it lacks the outright power and refinement of the Porsche 718. The Porsches interior quality, more powerful engine options definitely gives it an edge over the Alpine. The 718 delivers a more rounded package that’s as equally at home on track as it is on a daily commute.
Porsche 718 vs Audi TT RS
The Audi TT RS is a high-tech powerhouse with a 2.5-litre five-cylinder engine and Quattro all-wheel drive, making it a bit of a rocket in a straight line. It’s also packed with the latest Audi tech, offering a luxurious and modern interior. However, the TT RS’s heavier, front-engine layout doesn’t provide the same driving engagement as the 718. Where the 718 excels is in its razor-sharp handling and perfect weight distribution.
Porsche 718 vs Toyota GR Supra
The Toyota GR Supra brings a strong challenge with its powerful inline-six engine, rear-wheel drive, and sporty design. Co-developed with BMW, the Supra shares much with the Z4 but offers a slightly more aggressive edge. While the Supra is fast and fun, the Porsche 718’s steering, chassis, and overall driving experience are more finely honed. The 718 feels more connected with the road while the Supra, although impressive, doesn’t quite deliver the same level of driver feedback.
Porsche 718 vs. BMW Z4 M40i
The BMW Z4 M40i is a luxurious roadster that shares its platform with the Toyota GR Supra. It offers a blend of comfort and performance, with a powerful straight-six engine and an open-top driving experience. While the Z4 has decent performance, it more a comfortable cruiser than an out-and-out sports car. The Porsche 718, particularly in its Boxster form, offers a purer, more focused sports car experience with sharper handling and a more direct connection to the road.
Conclusion: Why we think the Porsche 718 Triumphs
As Porsche specialists we may be biased however, across the board, the Porsche 718 stands out for its impeccable balance, precision, and the unique driving pleasure that only a mid-engine sports car can offer. While each of its rivals brings something unique to the table, the 718 remains the quintessential sports car for those who prioritise driving experience above all else.